-
This Article demonstrates that and does not violate the Seventh Amendment. Two historical antecedents, used by common-law courts, justify modern summary judgment, trial by inspection and demurrer to the evidence. Trial by inspection, as explained by Blackstone, Coke, and Maitland, allowed a common-law judge to inspect evidence visually and then decide "obvious" cases without ever impaneling a jury. In contrast, a jury would be used if pretrial inspection demonstrated legitimate "doubt" about the relevant issue. Demurrer to the evidence, while not identical to summary judgment, is similar because it allowed a judge to take a case away from a jury where the nonmovant's evidence failed to prove a claim or defense. The Article criticizes a rigid interpreta...
-
Summary judgment is unconstitutional. This Symposium Article summarizes this thesis, which was first set forth in Why Summary Judgment Is Unconstitutional, published by the Virginia Law Review. This Article also describes the attention that the thesis has begun to receive in the federal courts and in the media.
-
[...] copying whether sought to be proven through evidence of access and similarities or striking or probative similarities, is most likely to be absent upon an alleged infringer's motion for summary judgment.
-
The Ontario Court of Appeal recently heard a number of cases dealing with Ontario's new summary judgement rules. In deciding these cases, we hope the ...
-
-
Attorneys for the Chickasaw and Choctaw nations filed a motion Tuesday asking for partial summary judgment in their federal lawsuit over the Sardis Lake Reservoir.
Tribal attorney Michael Burrage said the filing was the appropriate step to clarify issues and protect the current legal process surrounding the lawsuit.
-
HOW BEST to defend a new class action in which you think your client does not belong? Make a strong showing right out of the gate, and seek an early d...
-
On December 5, 2011, a five-judge panel of the Ontario Court of Appeal released its decision in Combined Air Mechanical Services Inc v Flesch1 and pro...
-
Summary judgment is a manufacturer's goal in almost every case. Often, it's an uphill battle. For example, a recent Supreme Court decision has made su...
-